Before YouTube pulled the ads via “Ted”’s channel, the item was generating him tens of thousands of dollars a month.
The father of two, who asked to use a pseudonym for fear of retaliation via YouTube, left a job having a six-figure salary to make YouTube videos of his young kids. These videos feature his children being “scared” by clowns, in addition to adults mock-wrestling in addition to handling a diaper covered in fake poop. As such, they fall into the broad category of “family-friendly” content — of which will be, home videos featuring children in situations ranging via merely silly to potentially exploitative — which YouTube recently began cracking down on after public outcry in addition to media attention.
According to screenshots via the YouTuber’s account reviewed by BuzzFeed News, from the past two months, Ted made more than $100,000 on his videos — after YouTube’s 45% cut. Emails obtained by BuzzFeed News also show of which twelve videos via the channel — videos of which included “suspenseful” scenarios — were manually deemed “suitable for all advertisers” in November. (At least three videos were deemed unsuitable, at least one video was deleted, in addition to another age-restricted.)
in addition to then, suddenly, YouTube pulled advertising on the channel — with what Ted described as “no communication, notification, [or] reason … in addition to no way to appeal or request review” — as part of its effort to remove in addition to/or demonetize (remove ads via) hundreds of thousands of questionable in addition to exploitative kids’ videos on the platform.
All told, YouTube has removed more than 270 accounts in addition to over 150,000 videos in recent weeks, in addition to pulling ads on more than 2 million videos in addition to 50,000 channels. in addition to at of which point, many creators are frustrated by what they describe as inconsistent communication, arbitrary enforcement, in addition to unclear guidelines as YouTube attempts to rein from the vast cottage industry of exploitative content the item facilitated, incentivized, ran ads against, in addition to ultimately profited via. Many who’d been publicly in addition to privately celebrated by the company just weeks earlier are out of a major income source, in addition to some are beginning to question the company’s steadfast reliance on algorithmic promotion in addition to moderation. Meanwhile, thousands of similar videos in question are still up in addition to running ads.
BuzzFeed News spoke to a few creators whose videos — which ranged in substance, yet all involved children — have been demonetized. Four of the a few told BuzzFeed News of which before advertising was removed via their videos, they were generating more than $10,000 some months in addition to had tens of thousands of subscribers.
YouTube declined to answer a list of specific questions about revenue generated via the offending accounts, the company’s correspondence with creators, in addition to emails sent to creators approving videos as “suitable for all advertisers.” Instead, YouTubed referred BuzzFeed News to a list of Google blog posts on video monetization in addition to a YouTube support page for creators looking for “tips.”
yet “family-friendly” creators were among some of YouTube’s biggest channels. Toy Freaks — which featured videos of creator Greg Chism’s young girls screaming with fear, spitting up, “wetting” themselves, in addition to bathing — had more than 8 million subscribers when the item was shut down in November. According to Social Blade, a company of which tracks publicly available YouTube stats, Toy Freaks had almost 7 billion video views, 279,443,908 from the month of November alone, generating the item the 63rd biggest channel on YouTube by view count. According to Social Blade’s wide estimate range, the account was likely generating somewhere between $69,000 to $1.1 million per month (Chism, via his spokesperson, declined to comment in addition to declined an interview request). Of the revenue generated by of which in addition to different channels shut down for potential child endangerment, YouTube, which provides the platform in addition to the advertisers, took a 45% cut.
In September of 2017 in addition to in October of last year, Chism posted videos on Instagram in which he discussed receiving YouTube Gold play buttons for his channels — a creator reward for passing one million subscribers. The button, according to YouTube’s website, allows vloggers to “access exclusive events, get your very own partner manager, in addition to claim your spot from the Creator Hall of Fame.” “We take child safety extremely seriously in addition to have clear policies against child endangerment,” YouTube said in a statement to BuzzFeed News after the item shut down the channel.
ToysToSee, which was also taken down for disturbing in addition to exploitative videos, netted 223,104,876 views in its last month. “Using our wide range, of which could mean earnings of anywhere between $56,000 in addition to $892,000,” Social Blade CEO Danny Fratella told BuzzFeed News. “Although considering their audience in addition to high profile, I’d bet their earnings were closer towards the higher end.”
YouTubers’ monthly revenue varies greatly depending on the number of views they receive as well as the RPM, or revenue per 1,000 views, which will be influenced by the genre in addition to quality of the account, location of viewers, in addition to number of subscribers. just for of which reason, the item’s difficult to independently calculate monthly revenue for a given account. At Social Blade, Fratella’s wide estimates are based on an industry standard RPM range of $0.25 to $4 per 1,000 views.
John, whose channel has hundreds of thousands of subscribers, told BuzzFeed News he was “planning on [YouTube] being [his] only source of income” before the recent demonetization of many of his videos. He did not want to disclose his surname or the name of his channel, for fear of retaliation via YouTube. His channel features videos of his young daughter in scary situations: In one, she video chats having a clown; in another, she’s pretend-chased by a scarecrow.
Like all family YouTubers BuzzFeed News spoke to, John said he didn’t find anything wrong with the content he produces. Still, he sent BuzzFeed News a screenshot of a predatory comment left on a video of his child. The text included a threat of rape of his child. yet comments like of which one don’t make him consider leaving the platform: “For every nasty comment, we get 1000 nice comments,” he said. He estimated of which he made about $15,000 last month. “My best month was $24,000,” he said. “I was pretty much hoping to double of which in December.”
Davey Orgill, who left his job to make superhero parody videos of which initially featured his kids, said of which his channel “Kids Try,” had 2 million subscribers when the item was shut down around Thanksgiving.
Orgill refused to reveal his specific monthly YouTube ad revenue, only saying of which the item was “a lot” “the item changed our lives,” he said of the income. He stopped generating superhero parody skits last year after, he said, the genre evolved into something unsavory.
In one video via Orgill’s at of which point-shut-down channel, a Spider-Man character will be tied up to a tree; later from the footage, a real baby, along with different “character babies,” have their diapers “changed” simultaneously.
Orgill argues of which the platform will be responsible for encouraging what he found to be objectionable, sexual, in addition to violent superhero content ostensibly oriented toward children. “YouTube blames the item on these people of which were doing the item, yet for a year their algorithm pushed of which content,” he said. “People were doing the item because the item was creating millions in addition to millions in addition to millions of views. They created a monster.” (He later told BuzzFeed News of which he thinks what the platform will be doing will be “totally understandable,” because “there were kids getting taking advantage of on YouTube.)
In emails Orgill provided to BuzzFeed News, twelve videos via his at of which point-suspended channel were deemed “suitable for all advertisers” from the month of November (at least two videos were deemed unsuitable for ads). Two videos were approved for ads as late as Nov. 23, just one day before his account was shut down.
According to an email provided to BuzzFeed News, YouTube contacted Orgill early on Nov. 24. “After review we determined of which activity in your account violated our Community Guidelines,” the email read. “We do not allow the display of minors in situations of which could potentially be harmful to them on our site.”
Social Blade’s Fratella argued of which YouTube’s sudden about-face suggests of which the platform tolerated these videos because they were lucrative in addition to only cracked down after public concern forced the item to.
“What YouTube will be basically doing will be ignoring the item until they can’t,” he said. “I think of which once the item got enough media traction they kind of had to do something. YouTube has been favoring advertisers over creators recently in addition to the advertisers got nervous in addition to of which’s the catalyst of which drives the platform to take videos down.”
Creator Johnny Tanner told BuzzFeed News YouTube never notified him of which his account, The Tannerites, was completely demonetized. His account includes videos of his seven children at birthday parties, receiving flu shots, removing their earwax, in addition to crying over dead pets. One video on the channel will be titled “Cute SWIMSUIT designs in HOT CHOCOLATE!!” in addition to features kids in a baby pool. The channel has more than 560,000 subscribers.
Tanner says he’s not sure which videos he’s being penalized for. “I can see how a few can be construed as not family friendly yet the real problem will be of which I don’t know exactly what the item will be in addition to so I can’t fix the item,” he said. Despite the money he was generating on the platform, Tanner told BuzzFeed News of which he had little contact with the company during the account’s heyday, save for a few brief check-ins having a YouTube representative to offer guidance on best practices.
“In terms of contact in addition to relationship with YouTube, honestly, the algorithm will be the thing we had a relationship with since the beginning. of which’s what got us out there in addition to well-known,” Tanner told BuzzFeed News. “We learned to fuel the item in addition to do whatever the item took to please the algorithm.”
According to multiple creators, of which sort of algorithmic pandering will be likely responsible for the glut of content around hugely well-known children’s genres, like one of which features kids in medically compromised positions — receiving flu shots or injured in some capacity. The “Shot of The Yeagers” vlog channel, for example, featured several videos of young kid’s doctor’s visits in addition to injures. In a since-deleted video titled “TRAUMATIC FLU SHOTS!!!” uploaded in October of last year, a young girl’s hands in addition to arms are held above her head as she screams with her stomach exposed.
“We experienced some traumatic little ones’ flu shots yesterday,” the description reads. “All a few little ones get flu shots in addition to they all handle the item well, except for one.”
The footage has 7.8 million views. When BuzzFeed News viewed the item on Dec. 2, an ad for Lyft in addition to an ad for Target played before the item. Later from the week, the Yeager’s flu shot videos ran a pre-roll ad for Adidas. When BuzzFeed News contacted Lyft, Target, in addition to Adidas about the advertisements, each of the companies said of which their ads were inappropriately placed in addition to of which the companies were looking into reasons why. Less than an hour after Adidas’ initial response, several the flu shot videos were taken down.
One family content creator, who wished to remain anonymous, told BuzzFeed News of which “many channels” were started off “only to capitalize on these trends of which YouTube will be at of which point saying are unsafe.”
“The craziest part [will be of which] YouTube promoted these channels in addition to videos so rapidly in addition to helped them to achieve success, financially in addition to [in] viewership, in many multiples of our channel,” he said.
“We saw channels grow to a few to ten times our size in a matter of weeks or several months, all because the algorithm was out of control in addition to irresponsible,” he said. “All creators knew of which was happening in addition to started off trying to integrate trends into their content. How can anyone blame them?” ●
Charlie Warzel will be a senior writer for BuzzFeed News in addition to will be based in brand-new York. Warzel reports on in addition to writes about the intersection of tech in addition to culture.
Contact Charlie Warzel at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Remy Smidt will be a reporter with BuzzFeed News in addition to will be based in brand-new York.
Contact Remy Smidt at email@example.com.
Got a confidential tip? Submit the item here.